Would Lord of the Flies Be the Same with Girls?

Book Roundup, Discussion, Young Adult Books
All-Girl Lord of the Flies | Could Lord of the Flies happen with all girls? Here are five young adult books that explore teenage friendships and grasps for power. | Books for fans of Lord of the Flies | Lord of the Flies movie | batchofbooks.com

Hollywood is producing a Lord of the Flies movie—reimagined with girls instead of boys. The movie is being written by two men, which is a pain point for a lot of people, but that doesn’t bother me. Lots of men that can write female characters admirably. John Green and Soman Chainani are two authors that do it well.

 

If you’ve never read Lord of the Flies before, here’s the Goodreads synopsis:

When a plane crashes on a remote island, a small group of schoolboys are the sole survivors. From the prophetic Simon and virtuous Ralph to the lovable Piggy and brutish Jack, each of the boys attempts to establish control as the reality – and brutal savagery – of their situation sets in.

The boys’ struggle to find a way of existing in a community with no fixed boundaries invites readers to evaluate the concepts involved in social and political constructs and moral frameworks. Ideas of community, leadership, and the rule of law are called into question as the reader has to consider who has a right to power, why, and what the consequences of the acquisition of power may be. Often compared to Catcher in the Rye, Lord of the Flies also represents a coming-of-age story of innocence lost.

 

While I actually like the idea of an all-female movie based around the same theme, I’m having a difficult time wrapping my head around this one. Here’s why:

1. Lord of the Flies is About Boys

You change it to girls, and it’s not Lord of the Flies anymore. It’s something else. I’m a stickler for keeping movies as close to the book as possible. If you want to make a movie featuring girls in a Lord of the Flies situation, then find a book like that. There are plenty to choose from.

2. Girls are Different

Lord of the Flies is about how young boys deal with the situation. Girls are different. They don’t deal with things the same way. Now, I’m not saying that the story wouldn’t be disastrous or deadly—because girls can be vicious. But the story would unravel in a different way.

3. Who Liked that Book Anyway?

Be honest. You hated it as much as I did. I understand why it’s an important work of literature and blah, blah, blah. But it left me feeling like:

via GIPHY

 

4. Why Not Pick a Book About Girls?

Everyone knows the title Lord of the Flies. By making a movie “based” on the book, you already have thousands and thousands of interested customers. We’ve all read and cringed over that book. A lesser known book will bring smaller audiences and a smaller paycheck. However, I would love to see a movie made from a book that used a cast of (mostly) female characters.

And, because I can’t resist an excuse to make a good book list, here you go.

 

Female-Powered Books for Lord of the Flies Fans

And just so you know, the links are affiliate links. If you make a purchase after clicking on one of my links, I’ll receive a small kickback.

 

Dare Me by Megan Abbot | A high-school cheerleading squad is a dangerous place for a girl to be. | Books for fans of Lord of the Flies | batchofbooks.comDare Me by Megan Abbott

Add to Goodreads >>

This book explores female friendship, jealousy, and the lengths girls will go to in order to maintain their position in society. Gillian Flynn said this book is like “Lord of the Flies set in a high-school cheerleading squad.” There are grasps for top-girl status and desperate reaches for power.

Amazon | Book Depository

 

A Map for Wrecked Girls by Jessica Taylor | Two teenage sisters and a teen boy get stranded on a tropical island and struggle to survive. | Books for fans of Lord of the Flies. | batchofbooks.comA Map for Wrecked Girls by Jessica Taylor

Add to Goodreads >>

Two sisters and a teenage boy get shipwrecked on a beautiful tropical island with nothing but their secrets. The sisters’ relationship is falling apart, but in order to survive in their new environment, they need to come together.

Amazon | Book Depository

 

Beauty Queens by Libba Bray | Books for fans of Lord of the FliesBeauty Queens by Libba Bray

Add to Goodreads >>

An airplane full of beauty pageant contestants crash lands on a desert island. Now the girls are left wondering if they should be worried about the pageant or worried about survival. It’s a madcap survival story that promises laughter, feminism, and witty banter.

Amazon | Book Depository

 

Little Monsters by Kara Thomas | Kacey's new life seems too good to be true until one of her friends goes missing. | Books for fans of Lord of the Flies | batchofbooks.comLittle Monsters by Kara Thomas

Add to Goodreads >>

When Kacey moves in with her dad and his new family, everything seems wonderful at first. She makes some friends and everyone is really nice—until one of her friends goes missing and fingers start pointing. This book is a look at the darker side of teenage friendships and the dangers that lurk there.

Amazon | Book Depository

 

Forest of a Thousand Lanterns by Julie C. DaoForest of a Thousand Lanterns by Julie C. Dao

Add to Goodreads >>

This book set in an East-Asian fantasy world, but it explores similar themes. It’s a retelling of Snow White’s evil stepmother’s story. It deals with female ambition and jealousy. The main character is an anti-heroine whose hunger for power turns her into a blood-thirsty monster.

Amazon | Book Depository

 

What do you think of an all-female Lord of the Flies movie?

 

Want More Book Recommendations?
Browse for book recommendations by age using the “Books by Age” tab in the top navigation bar. Then, sign up for my weekly-ish newsletter to stay up to date on new giveaways, author interviews, book lists, and other awesomeness! Sign up now.

Save

Previous Story
Next Story

No Comments

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: